Breast and Ovarian Cancer in the Family: What to Ask at Thanksgiving
Thanksgiving is one of the few days when several generations may share a table or a video call. It can also be a good time to ask a question that rarely comes up: who in the family has had cancer, and how old were they when it was found?
Many women know only part of the answer. An aunt had “some kind of female cancer,” a grandmother’s illness was never discussed, or a father’s side of the family feels like a blank page. Those missing details can matter, because certain patterns of breast and ovarian cancer may point to an inherited change in the BRCA1 or BRCA2 genes.
This guide explains which family patterns health agencies highlight, what details are worth writing down, how to bring up the subject gently, and what genetic counseling and testing can and cannot show.
Why BRCA Genes Come Up in Family History
Everyone has BRCA1 and BRCA2 genes. Certain harmful changes in these genes raise the risk of breast and ovarian cancer, along with pancreatic and prostate cancer. The National Cancer Institute estimates that about 0.2% to 0.3% of the general population carries a harmful change, so most people do not. The rate is higher in some groups, including about 2% of people of Ashkenazi Jewish descent.
A harmful change does not skip over men. According to the CDC, each child of a person with a BRCA mutation has a 1 in 2 chance of having it too, and that applies whether the parent is a mother or a father. This is why a father’s relatives belong in the family history just as much as a mother’s.
Having cancer in the family does not by itself mean a harmful gene change is present. Family history is a starting point that helps a clinician decide whether a closer look makes sense.
Family Patterns Worth Mentioning to Your Doctor
The CDC lists family history features that may suggest a higher chance of a BRCA change. None of these confirms an inherited change, but each is useful for a doctor to know.
- Several relatives with breast cancer
- Any relative with ovarian cancer
- A relative diagnosed with breast cancer before age 50
- A relative with cancer in both breasts
- A relative who had both breast and ovarian cancer
- A male relative with breast cancer
- Ashkenazi Jewish ancestry along with any relative who had breast or ovarian cancer
- A relative known to carry a BRCA mutation
Your Own Health History Counts Too
Personal history matters as well. The CDC’s list includes breast cancer before age 50, triple-negative breast cancer, and ovarian, fallopian tube, or primary peritoneal cancer at any age. The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force recommendation also covers women who finished treatment for one of these cancers, are considered cancer free, and have never had testing.
Other Cancers That Can Be Part of the Picture
The National Cancer Institute also notes that pancreatic cancer, male breast cancer, and metastatic or high-risk prostate cancer in the family can make a harmful change more likely. A family history focused only on women could miss these clues.
What to Write Down at the Holiday Table
A family history does not need to be perfect to be useful. A few specifics are often more helpful than a long story, and “I don’t know” is an acceptable answer. Parents, siblings, children, grandparents, aunts, uncles, nieces, and nephews are good places to start.
Houston is home to many families with relatives in other states and other countries, so some of this may need a phone call or message after the meal. Older relatives may remember details no one else knows. The CDC’s free My Family Health Portrait: Cancer Edition app is one way to keep the information organized.
- Who the relative is and which side of the family they are on
- The type of cancer, and where it started if anyone knows
- The age at diagnosis, even if it is only an estimate
- Whether cancer occurred in both breasts or more than once
- Family ancestry, including any Ashkenazi Jewish heritage
- Any known genetic test result, including the name of the specific mutation
Starting the Conversation Without Spoiling the Meal
Cancer can be a painful subject, and some relatives may prefer privacy. A quiet moment with one person often works better than raising the topic in front of the whole table. It can help to explain the reason plainly: the information may be useful for everyone’s health, including the younger generation.
If someone would rather not talk, that choice deserves respect. Another relative may be able to help, or the person may feel ready later.
If a relative already knows of a BRCA mutation, the CDC encourages sharing the exact mutation, since this helps other relatives’ doctors choose the right test. The CDC also notes that genetic testing is usually not recommended for children, and that conversations with children can follow their own pace and readiness.
From Family Notes to Risk Assessment
The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force recommends that clinicians use a brief risk assessment tool for women whose personal history, family history, or ancestry is linked to harmful BRCA changes. Women with a positive result on that tool should be offered genetic counseling and then testing if counseling shows it is appropriate. The current recommendation dates from 2019, and the Task Force lists an update as in progress.
The Task Force recommends against routine risk assessment, counseling, or testing for women without these histories or ancestry. Testing everyone is not the goal, which makes a good family history especially useful in sorting out who may benefit.
Counseling helps people learn whether they and their family are likely to benefit from testing and which tests fit best. When possible, the CDC says testing should begin with a family member who has had breast, ovarian, or another BRCA-related cancer.
What Test Results Can and Cannot Tell You
Genetic results can be more nuanced than a simple yes or no. The National Cancer Institute and CDC describe three broad kinds of results.
Positive
A harmful change was found and cancer risk is increased. The result cannot show whether or when cancer will develop. People in this situation can review options with their care team, which may include earlier or more intensive screening and other risk-reducing approaches, each with its own benefits and harms.
Negative
The test did not find the change it was looking for. If a close relative has a known mutation and it was not found, the person did not inherit that mutation and cannot pass it on. A negative result does not mean cancer will never occur, and family history may still point to higher risk.
Variant of Uncertain Significance
A gene change was found, but there is not enough information to know its effect on cancer risk. Most of these variants are later reclassified as benign. Until more is known, care decisions rely on family history and other risk factors.
The Bottom Line
A few careful questions at Thanksgiving can fill in gaps that may matter for years. Knowing who had breast, ovarian, or related cancers, on which side of the family, and at what age gives a doctor something concrete to assess.
Most families will not turn out to carry a harmful BRCA change, and a concerning pattern is not a diagnosis. Even so, writing the history down is a practical gift to the people at the table and to generations who are not yet there. This article is general information and is not a substitute for personal medical advice.
Readers who gather new family details this season can bring their notes to their own doctor and ask whether a risk assessment makes sense for them.
Sources
- People at Increased Risk for BRCA Gene Mutations (CDC)
- Genetic Testing for Hereditary Breast and Ovarian Cancer (CDC)
- Talking to Family About Your BRCA Gene Mutation (CDC)
- BRCA Gene Changes: Cancer Risk and Genetic Testing (National Cancer Institute)
- BRCA-Related Cancer: Risk Assessment, Genetic Counseling, and Genetic Testing (U.S. Preventive Services Task Force)