HPV Test, Pap Test, or Both? Making Sense of Cervical Cancer Screening
As the year winds down, many women look back over their health checklist and wonder which screenings are due. Cervical cancer screening often prompts the most questions, because the advice has changed over the years. The yearly Pap smear many women grew up with is no longer the only option, and for many adults it is not the usual one.
There are now three main screening approaches, start ages differ slightly between expert groups, and the waiting time between tests depends on which test was used and what it showed. On top of that, a result such as “HPV positive” can sound alarming without context. It is easy to feel unsure whether a screening is overdue, or whether a result means something serious.
This guide explains what the HPV test and the Pap test each look for and how often screening is generally recommended at different ages. It also covers when screening may stop, what results usually mean, and which questions may help when talking with your doctor.
Two Tests, Two Different Questions
Cervical cancer screening is meant to find changes on the cervix before they become cancer, while they can still be treated. The National Cancer Institute explains that screening is done before any symptoms appear, which is why it matters even for women who feel completely well.
The two main tests answer different questions. The HPV test looks for high-risk types of human papillomavirus, the virus that can cause the cell changes that lead to cervical cancer. The Pap test (also called a Pap smear or cervical cytology) looks directly at cervical cells for changes that could become cancer. According to the CDC, both can be collected during the same office visit, and the cells are sent to a lab.
When both tests are run on the same sample, it is called co-testing. Many women may not realize which test, or which combination, was done at their last visit. That detail matters, because it affects when the next screening is due.
- HPV test: checks for high-risk HPV types linked to cervical cancer
- Pap test: checks cervical cells for precancerous changes
- Co-test: both tests run on the same sample
How Often Screening Is Generally Recommended
For women at average risk, guidance from the CDC and the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force follows a fairly consistent pattern by age. The CDC advises starting Pap tests at age 21. The National Cancer Institute notes that Pap testing isn’t needed before 21, even for women who are sexually active.
The American Cancer Society takes a slightly different approach: it recommends starting at age 25 with an HPV test every five years, while still accepting co-testing or Pap testing as alternatives, as the NCI summarizes. These differences are one reason a conversation with your doctor is useful for deciding which schedule fits.
Ages 21 to 29
Under USPSTF and CDC guidance, screening in this age group is usually a Pap test every three years when results are normal. MedlinePlus notes that HPV infections are especially common in people in their twenties and usually clear on their own within a year or two, which is part of why the approach differs for younger adults.
Ages 30 to 65
In this range, there are three accepted options: an HPV test alone every five years, co-testing every five years, or a Pap test alone every three years, as long as results are normal (CDC). Your doctor can help weigh which option makes sense based on your history.
Collecting Your Own Sample
One newer option is self-collection for HPV testing. Instead of a clinician collecting the sample during a pelvic exam, the patient collects it herself in a private space within a health care setting. MedlinePlus describes inserting a swab or brush into the vagina to a marked point, rotating it to gather cells, and returning it to the care team.
For some women, this can make screening feel more comfortable or less stressful. The National Cancer Institute suggests asking a health care provider whether self-collection is available. Not every setting offers it, and your doctor can explain whether it suits your situation and history.
Getting Ready for the Visit
Preparation is simple. The CDC notes that no special preparation is needed for an HPV test. Before a Pap test, it advises avoiding intercourse, douching, vaginal medicines, and spermicidal products for two days, because these can affect the sample.
If plans don’t go perfectly, the CDC still encourages keeping the appointment and simply telling the doctor. Both tests can also be done during a period.
Understanding Your Results
Results can take up to about three weeks to come back. If you haven’t heard anything, the NCI encourages contacting your provider rather than assuming no news is good news.
An HPV test result is either positive or negative. A negative result means high-risk HPV was not found. A positive result means it was found. As MedlinePlus explains, that does not mean precancer or cancer is present, but it does raise future risk. Pap results may come back normal, unclear, abnormal, or “unsatisfactory.” An unsatisfactory result means the lab couldn’t read the sample well, so the test may need to be repeated (CDC).
If a result is abnormal, your care team decides on next steps using your age, past results, and health history. Options may include repeat testing or a colposcopy, a closer look at the cervix with a magnifying instrument (MedlinePlus).
When Screening May Stop
Screening doesn’t necessarily continue for life. The CDC explains that women over 65 may be able to stop if they have had several normal results in the past 10 years, generally at least three normal Pap tests or two negative HPV tests, and no history of cervical precancer. Women who haven’t been screened regularly, or who have had recent abnormal results, may need to continue (NCI).
Hysterectomy also changes the picture, but only depending on what was removed and why. According to the NCI, women whose uterus and cervix were both removed for reasons unrelated to cancer or precancer generally don’t need screening. Women who had only the uterus removed, with the cervix left in place, should continue routine screening.
Questions Worth Bringing to Your Doctor
A short conversation can clear up most of the confusion around cervical screening. Dr. V’s educational approach emphasizes understanding the reasoning behind a recommendation, not just the schedule. These questions can help guide that conversation.
- Which test did I have last time, and when?
- Which screening option fits my age and history?
- Is self-collection an option for me?
- If my result was abnormal, what are the next steps and why?
- Do any of my health conditions mean I should be screened more often?
- Based on my history, will I be able to stop screening at some point?
The Bottom Line
Cervical cancer screening has become more flexible. Depending on age and history, it may involve a Pap test, an HPV test, or both, and how long to wait before the next test depends on which was used and what it showed. Abnormal results are common and usually do not mean cancer, but they do call for clear follow-up with your care team.
The end of the year is a natural time to check whether screening is up to date and to settle any lingering questions about past results. This article is general information and is not a substitute for personal medical advice from your own doctor.
If you’re unsure when your next cervical screening is due, talk with your own doctor, or explore more of Dr. V’s women’s health articles to keep learning.